This game was proof Coughlin needs to go. I'm not surprised at the result especially after last week and the fact that Green Bay gave New England a close game with their backup QB. The Giants organization needs some serious overall right now. Head coach, offense coach, defense coach, RB's that fumble and Eli still can't make adjustments like he should be doing by now in his career. Guessing at where a receiver might end up doesn't cut it. And to think a bunch of the NFL experts thought the Giants had the best team in the NFC back in week 4 or 5. :lol: I think I said back then that they weren't a good team. Time for rebuilding, no reason to see how long you can drag out a combination that doesn't work. The only reason Coughlin won a SuperBowl was because of the defense(and def coordinator) that year. Next week Chicago vs Green Bay should be a really good game.

The Rams and Seahawks and Tampa and NO will be good games as well..


Its funny how you say that this combo doesnt work when you have a SB victory with this coach and QB... Yes the D was the main reason that the Giants won the SB but it was still a pass from Eli that won the game.

and one lucky catch :evil:
i hated it! :lol:

That play and the pass to Plaxico for the winning TD..

IMO the Giants got hot at the right time and played above their means.

...and Giants fans I'm not saying to that be a dick or to start drama. I really think they played better than they should have and things just happened to come together at the right time.

When I watched those playoffs in '07, I was thinking more why couldn't they have played like this during the season? Because they were obviously capable of doing it. Their playoff run proved it. It wasn't a matter of playing better than they should have. Rather, it was playing the way they should have played all along. I think what the Giants do a lot is play below their means. With the talent the Giants have, they should have 10-12 wins already this season.

Was that due to the players playing better or the coaches coaching better?

lol probably because coughlins head was on the line and he pushed them far....spagnolo has a lot to do with that ring they got....hell look at what he's done in st louis already. he's turned them into contenders

winning a division at 8-8 is not contending

it is when the year before they went 1-15.

Does it really matter?

To me it doesnt as I couldnt really care but it is interesting to see what giants fans think. would they like to see a better QB with the same coaching staff like we did this past year with Kolb/Vick or would they like to see the same players with a new Coaching staff..

Look at what the Flyers did after changing coaches last season in the middle of the season. Coughlin needs to go but I'm not thrilled with the 2 starting RB's with their fumbling problems and Eli is still a big question mark. There aren't too many decent QB's in the NFL so I wouldn't want to give up Eli until they made other changes first. I still can't figure out how they were the 2nd ranked defense in the NFL going into yesterdays game.

...and tonight's game is exactly why the Eagles won't win a Super Bowl...with or without Vick. Absolutely horrible D and a hole-filled O-line.

Vick wasnt steller either.. Should have had 3 more INT's to go along with his 3 other TO's Shaddy is probably there best all around player and its only his 2nd year.. I would bench Vick for the last game and put Kolb in to give Vick some rest.

Yeah, Eagles have nothing to gain next week so you want to sit out the key players. It always amazes me when a team trying to either make the playoffs or improve their position can't get the job done. 5 years ago it almost never happened, but the last few years the team in the position to win and either clinch or improve isn't getting it done. It sure seems like the teams with nothing to gain realize they're playing for their future and do the job they should have been doing all year. The fact that New Orleans can still actually get home field and/or a bye week at this point is stunning. They keep getting healthier every week which makes them look better and better. Their defense is suspect but then so is everyone else in the NFC. The SuperBowl could be a real toss up this year.

contending means to have a chance at actually winning a playoff game

But with the way the NFC is this year anyone has a chance at winning the NFC.

not the west lol


you could have put buffalo in the nfc west this year and they would have 10 wins