Go with the gray. I dont think the black held up as well as it should have. Maybe it was the quality of the sweatshirt? IDK. I didnt wear mine all the time but its been a year and it looks like its 15 years old. New year.....new color......change is always good
Depending on the shade of gray I would debate the print color. If its a dark color gray then you might have issues with seeing the print.....so maybe another color with the font. Light gray....not a fan of...it gets dirty way to easy!! Hopefully I was of some assistance with my opinion
