i'm sorry to hear that you have to sell off your toys
i know this vote won't be popular but the honda fit is still the most fun to drive of the subcompacts. unfortunately your doing this at a bad time because most little cars have markups. if you need storage, don't forget to check out the HHR. i know a guy on TCL traded in his G35 for a HHR base model with a 5-speed and said he's happy as heck.
edit: go to fueleconomy.gov for real world data